By 24 September 2011 13 Comments Read More →

Tested : Optare Solo Eco-Drive

Mike Humble goes On The Buses, dons his drivers cap and brushes up on his Phwoars and Cor Blimey’s whilst getting behind the wheel of the latest bus built in the plant which was at one time part of the British Leyland empire – the Optare Solo Eco Drive, and finds it rather good fun!

The Optare Solo EcoDrive - A hoot to drive

The Optare Solo EcoDrive – A hoot to drive

Over the years, many once great names in the bus & coach world have simply faded away or lost their identity. Firms such as AEC, Bedford & Leyland – once global leaders in chassis building, have closed their doors while body building names like Duple, Harrington & Willowbook also are now just a fond memory from days gone by when your bus had an open platform and your fare would be collected in a leather shoulder bag by a traditional conductor or “clippie”.

Having spent a while in the bus industry, I often get asked if the job really was as cushy as depicted by Stan Butler and his trusty clippie Jack, although I never worked in that era, I can say through knowing many a time served driver and having driven a few classic half cab  buses, it was a seriously harsh environment with long hours for little pay.  Wrestling with the non power assisted steering, while a thumping great 10.45 litre Gardner diesel gently roasts your left leg and makes your eyes stream with fuel & breather fumes was far from an ideal working environment, let alone the brutal clutch and unforgiving crash gearbox sending various vibrations through your body.

The howls, whines and growls of yesteryear’s buses have given way to almost vacuum cleaner type noises, the once damp and smoky upper decks with coarse leatherette trims and screw fit 40 watt light bulbs have been replaced with bright airy and inviting places with air conditioning , soft cloth moquette and relaxing modern LED lighting. Modern buses are in fact just as easy to drive as a car, with the engines often fitted many metres behind, the driver is isolated from the vibration and noise.

Power steering, ABS & air suspension is now not even thought of where once upon a time, and not that long ago, the thought of these items would make the average fleet engineer pull faces of disgust. So even though modern buses lack the character and charm we once loved, they provide a clean and safe environment for the passenger while at the same time giving the driver a decent working environment. The 1980`s ushered in a new trend of mini and midi buses with offerings like the Dennis Dart – MCW / Optare Metrorider and to a lesser extent, our very own Leyland Swift. The most popular of the smaller minibus was the Metrorider which was replaced in the late 90`s by the cute looking Solo, the only minibus I have had a soft spot for.

Optare was formed in the mid 1980`s following the decision by Leyland to close the C.H Roe body works in Leeds. The workers of Roe armed with redundancy payments headed by Russell Richardson formed a management buy out thus forming Optare which for the record, is a Greek word meaning “To Choose”. The Solo at launch turned the idea of the mini bus on its head by offering a vehicle that was styled with the passenger in mind, curvy and sleek with a wheel at each corner, the Solo was quickly accepted by the once cautious operators and both driver and passenger loved them.

Power units are supplied by either Cummins or Mercedes Benz with Allison automatic gearboxes with electro magnetic retarders. Most of the braking system is supplied via Iveco and what made the Solo unique at the time, was the front axle being ahead of the front doors offering a huge platform area with no intrusion into the front passenger seat area. Stepless entry with wheelchair ramp allied with kneeling air suspension means boarding the bus is a doddle thanks to its full size 2 leaf front door. The vehicle I operated in service for a whole Saturday was the Mercedes powered EcoDrive.

The EcoDrive is just as high tech and modern as your average Golf Blue Motion or Ford Econetic with an engine that shuts down after a period of idling in neutral. Fueling is combined with Ad Blue and the dashboard has an economy dial replacing the usual rev counter.

What suprised me was the Driver Skill counter and four vertical bands which warn the driver of harsh acceleration, deceleration, economy and wait for it…. a G meter that tells you how smoothly you go round corners – most bizarre for a bus, but I do see the point though I wondered if the driver of today has enough to keep an eye on with suicidal pedestrians with baby buggies, cars and countless other obstacles as well as jolly coloured warning lights and dials. Telematics is the buzz word in today’s bus and truck, with the operators able to download real time info from the vehicles brain pin pointing drivers who drive without sympathy or care.

In this ever increasingly cost driven world, every penny counts and I applaud this kind of modern technology. The Solo has superb brakes, steering,  comfort and impressive visibility thanks to its truly massive windscreen, all the incidental switches are located on a soft touch control pad to your right hand side leaving the left area totally clutter free.

Bonkers dash panel with "driver skill" readout!

Bonkers dash panel with “driver skill” readout!

Driver checking procedures are helped by the vast amount of room in the rear engine bay with sight glasses for coolant and esy to reach dipstick for oil levels. All other functions such as electronics and other technical magic and wizzardy are silently observed by the vehicles system computer. The Solo is fitted with four 5in halogen headlamps making night driving a cinch while the interior lights being mounted flush to the saloon ceiling, don’t reflect in the huge windscreen too much – a major problem on some types.

The air suspended drivers seat irons out all but the most severe of ruts or bumps and the thick chunky steering wheel (as seen on the Iveco EuroCargo) is a far cry from the cold hard bake-o-lite affairs of old, it’s also adjustable for height and reach. I could go as far as saying thats it’s quite possibly the comfiest and most appealing little bus I have driven in years. Mini buses traditionally had a bucking bronco ride comfort, not so with the Solo thanks to a long wheelbase. It rides well and corners with little body roll, but care needs to be taken in wet or icy weather to avoid understeer owing to the bulk of the vehicles weight being towards the rear.

Performance from the Merc engine is lively enough and refined, though its a touch agricultural on tick over reminding you that after all it’s only a 4 cylinder unit. The gearbox is noise free and changes up and down with a jerk free manner, strangely though, there is no kick down position on the pedal because the the clever ECU monitors the load upon the engine and road speed constantly – it quite literally thinks for you.

One thing I did find odd was getting used to the wheels being inches away from the front bumper. Traditionally, you would sweep the body work over the kerb to align the edge to the side of the entry step. Once or twice I found myself scraping or bumping the kerb with the front wheel but once used to its wheel base I found the bus a sweet little thing to pilot around the tight narrow roads in Worthing and changing my views about minibuses in general. An average 10 hour shift in the Solo brought no complaints from myself in its construction or ability of moving passengers from A to B. Its stylish, great to drive, supremely economical, has a lovely bright and airy interior that seems well screwed together and above all British, I was chuffed to bits with it!

Inviting Interior - A far cry from the damp austerity of old buses!

Inviting Interior – A far cry from the damp austerity of old buses!

I do miss the growl of a Leyland Leopard the metalic whine of a National and the scream from the transmission of a Bristol VR reminds me of being a child sitting on the back seat of the service 141 from Keddington to Cambridge on Saturday mornings as the driver would nudge 60mph flying down Linton bank. Nostalgia is a lovely thing, but they were pigs to drive for a full shift and the guys and girls who drove those half cab Bristols, Daimlers & Leyland’s of old get my total full respect!

“now come on you lot…. Get That Bus Out”

Mike Humble

Mike Humble

Upon leaving school, Mike was destined to work on the Railway but cars were his first love. An apprenticeship in a large family Ford dealer was his first forray into the dark and seedy world of the motor trade.

Moving on to Rover and then PSV / HGV, he has circumnavigated most departments of dealerships including parts, service and latterly - the showroom. Mike has owned all sorts of rubbish from Lada to Leyland and also holds both Heavy Goods & Public Service Vehicle licences, he buys & sells buses and coaches during the week. Mike runs his own automotive web site and writes for a number of motoring or commercial vehicle themed publications
Mike Humble
Posted in: Essays, The bus section
Mike Humble

About the Author:

Upon leaving school, Mike was destined to work on the Railway but cars were his first love. An apprenticeship in a large family Ford dealer was his first forray into the dark and seedy world of the motor trade. Moving on to Rover and then PSV / HGV, he has circumnavigated most departments of dealerships including parts, service and latterly - the showroom. Mike has owned all sorts of rubbish from Lada to Leyland and also holds both Heavy Goods & Public Service Vehicle licences, he buys & sells buses and coaches during the week. Mike runs his own automotive web site and writes for a number of motoring or commercial vehicle themed publications

13 Comments on "Tested : Optare Solo Eco-Drive"

Trackback | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Dennis says:

    Got those horrible Iveco column stalks though. They always sound like they’ve snapped every time you use them. Actually they feel like they will as soon as you touch them. I’ve never actually seen anyone manage the bust one of them though!

  2. David 3500 says:

    The Driver Skill Counter is an interesting concept – does it save the information relating to the driver’s driving style for the Transport Manager to analysis, in a similar way as a tachograph saves data relating to the operating time of the vehicle?

  3. Dennis says:

    Well the isotrak systems in trucks relay the drivers performance back to base in real time. If for example you idle excessively then the base get’s it flagged up and it all goes into a spreadsheet for each driver.

  4. Evans says:

    Give me a Dennis Dart any day!!!!

  5. Mikey C says:

    It’s weird that Optare is the only part of the Leyland/AEC/Bristol/Daimler/Park Royal/ECW/Roe/Guy etc bus empire that still exists in the UK, and even they have just relocated to a new factory…

  6. BobM BobM says:

    Evans – I’m with you there! Solo’s age horribly, it doesn’t take long for them to crash and bang about. I’ve never liked ’em and doubt I ever will.

    A Pointer Dart with an ISBe cummins engine is a proper bus – end of! Shame they don’t make them any more.

  7. Mikey C says:

    There’s a few round my part of London, operating a few hail and ride routes, they sometimes operate on normal routes and are grossly inferior to the VDL Wright Cadets to ride in

  8. Mike Humble Mike Humble says:

    VDL do a nice product, sadly with controlled prices with most going to Arriva who incidentally are also the sole importer.

    The latest Optare stuff is pretty good that’s a gulf apart from a few years back.

  9. Marty B says:

    Optare electrics and quality are both still somewhat poor, especially on the Solo. Body panels and windows actually falling out are still fairly common too. I have never ever driven a Solo that was nice to drive. I find the driving position awful, and the drivers seats don’t go up high enough. The drony Mercedes & MAN engines are horrid, and the stupidly laggy electronic throttle..You plant your foot and their is a delay..WTF? Steering lock angle is a severe issue with all Solos, and a Dart is much easier to nip in and out of tight spots than a Solo. I found that I could get an 11m single deck round estates way better than a Solo that was under 10m, and so could my colleagues. Solos also have a bit of a habit of going up in flames, especially when Mercedes powered. Grounding the rear end is also common on hilly routes. Sumps, exhausts and rear bumpers take a hammering. Seems to be worse on Cummins & MAN examples.

  10. BobM BobM says:

    Never driven a MAN engined Solo so I can’t comment. The Merc ones we have all suffer that stupid throttle delay, especially ones of an older vintage, though the newer ones are not so bad and are in fact slightly quicker. Cummins engined ones are the best, plenty of grunt although they seem to roll much more strangely enough. Well the ones we have do anyway.

  11. Marty B says:

    I’ve seen the latest press shots of the Indian Solo SR. It has revised frontal styling, complete with the old Leyland ‘Flying Plughole’ roundel on the front, and has an Indian made ‘Leyland’ engine!

  12. Suekie Suekie says:

    As a mere passenger, I can only say that in comparison to the square box refrigerator with transverse planks that still often passes for public transport round here, on the occasions we got one of these for the hour-and-a half twenty mile trip home (which I did for a year or so while temporarily car-less) it was pure luxury.
    So much so that I missed my stop on more than one occasion due to having dozed off.
    So they might have fault but are still a very large step in the right direction!

  13. Chris Baglin says:

    In Gloucester where I live these are the nicest buses to ride on, or would be if they didn’t discriminate against passengers of 6′ or more by forcing you to sit sideways as your legs won’t fit. In fairness, most Stagecoach buses that don’t come with old-fasioned thin benches are like this.

    Solos have a comfortable ride, the engines sound far more pleasant than the rather agricultural (and underpowered) Cummins 6 cylinders found in the dreadful Dennis/ Plaxton smokers they put on my local route (being mostly council estate, and therefore having a captive ridership, this is the route where the worst buses in the fleet are sent to die). Solos are also notably good accelerators.

    I can’t say I’ve noticed any real issues with Solo build quality- I’ve yet to ride on any bus that didn’t rattle after a few years, and Solos seem far better in that respect than the various older Dennises on the fleet, with their flimsy flapping internal panelwork almost purpose designed to drum very loudly and drown out conversation when the engine is idling. Of course, the fitters could easily stop that by putting in a bit of MDF behind them, but why bother when most of their passengers have no choice but to ride on them, and have to pay an extortionate £3.40 return for a journey of no more than 5 miles round trip into town? Oddly, Alexander /Dennis double deckers seem to be built to a much higher standard than their single decker equivalents.

Have your say...