The cars | Jaguar XJ40 | The rivals

Jaguar XJ40: the rivals

   Previous Page Next Page  

It might have been 13 years in the making, but the Jaguar XJ40 was genuinely one of the best cars in the world when it finally appeared on the scene in 1986...

We take a look at some of the cars it fought against during its production run - it seemed as though the Germans were the keenest opposition.


What the director ordered...

Audi V8: 1988-1996

Back in the Eighties, Audi was still considered a 'Wannabe' prestige manufacturer, and it's V8 was the company's first step in a bold plan to join the gentleman's club populated by BMW and Mercedes-Benz as well as Jaguar. The 3.6-litre V8 engine was tuneful and the quattro drivetrain fun, but overall, buyers weren't convinced, finding it too similar in appearance to the 100/200. A brave effort, rare now.

BMW 7-Series (E32): 1984-1991

The second generation BMW 7-Series arrived on the scene at the same time as the Jaguar XJ40 and the inevitable comparisons were made. Most tests concluded that the BMW outshone the Jaguar in terms of quality and engine refinement, but the Jaguar more than made up for these deficiencies on the road. As ever, BMW offered the sporting choice in the sector. BMW's V12 option turned up years before Jaguar's similarly powered XJ40.

Lexus LS400: 1989-1995

Toyota realised if it wanted to make it big in the prestige car market, it would need to come up with a new marque with which to sell them. Lexus was the name (meaning Luxury EXport US), and the LS400 was the car - engine refinement was class leading, and quality pummelled the opposition. In fact, the LS400 moved on the game considerably - although a few people would conclude it lacked character.

Mercedes-Benz S-Class: 1979-1991

The Mercedes-Benz W126 was a huge step forward when it was launched in 1979, but by the time the XJ40 appeared in 1986, it was getting past it. Always a world leader in terms of solidity, the S-Class was the favoured transport of world leaders and German minicab drivers, alike - people who know a thing or two about longevity. The S-Class' replacement in 1991 was also an XJ40 rival, but was far larger...


Verdict

OH, this is an easy one. Whereas the German and Japanese opposition oozed quality and sophistication, none could hold a candle to the Jagaur in terms of driving dynamics and that indefinable quality known as character. Yes, the XJ40's looks are a little awkward - and not exactly progressive - and the interior is cramped, but from behind the wheel, these are hardly problems.

Having said that, we love the bravery of the Audi, even if it doesn't stack up on the road, and is now causing owners a number of expensive headaches in the reliability department. As for the BMW and Mercedes-Benz, there's no doubting their engineering integrity - and in the case of the Stuttgart car, there's a throbby V8 to keep the driver entertained, if he chooses to take the 4-litre option.

As for the Lexus, you can't help but admire what Toyota achieved on an almost unlimited budget - and the awards were reaped in America, where badge snobbery isn't such an issue there.

But hand on heart - we'd plump for the Jaguar every time - and even if they weren't as cheap as they are secondhand, the XJ40's charms would be hard to deny...


With help from Mark Mastrototaro


   Previous Page Next Page  

Related pages:

· Jaguar XJ40 index page

The cars | Jaguar XJ40 | The rivals