Blog : Designing a new MG

Carole Nash Classic Insurance Specialists

Ben Richards has MG running through his veins. He’s also a very talented design graduate who decided it was time to design a new one of his own.

Here’s his story, in his own words, and also what it takes to design a new coupe. But will it lead to a future in the motor industry? Let’s hope!


University Design Project – MG 8 Coupe

MG8 Coupe

Since a young age, I’ve always had an obsession with cars. When asked what I wanted to do when I was older the answer was always “I want to make cars”. As I grew older, the understanding of the career I wanted transformed the answer to ‘I want to design cars’. I worked my way through the early stages of my education with that clear goal in mind – no need for careers advisers, I knew where I was going, what courses to take and where.

University was the beginning of the realisation of my ambition. For the first time I could spend whole days just drawing cars, and not just at home. I could talk to like-minded people who were as enthusiastic about cars as I was. It’s probably worth mentioning at this point that I went to Swansea Metropolitan University – I find a lot of people when presented with a Car Design student assume they went to Coventry! I learned about the various aspects of vehicle design, packaging etc. I even remember doing a presentation about the ergonomic strengths and weaknesses of my Rover 25!

During my first two years at the University, I quite often saw the third year students in the workshops building their final year models. It was something that I couldn’t wait to do myself and I already knew pretty much what I wanted to do. That brings me neatly on to the object of my automotive obsession, MG.

It was an odd one to explain. My dad had never owned them (although he did have two Austin Montegos and a Rover 214), and I can’t recall any family or friends owning them. I just liked them and, having liked them all my life, I knew I had to do an MG for my final year project. During my time at University I was well known as being the MG fan, many laughed and joked, and an untimely Head Gasket Failure on the 25 certainly helped pour fuel on the bonfire! I put up with it though because it was just banter and it’s what I’m in to. I can tell you nobody had or needed to ask me what my third year project would be, they could guess quite easily.

First and second years passed, all shapes and sizes of cars covered, and at one point even boats, the time had come. We were given submission forms and would have a meeting with our tutor regarding what we wanted to do in order to get it signed off. By this time, MG itself had been resurrected by NAC, and later SAIC. This helped me in some respect as, by looking at the concepts, it gave me something to align my concept to, so that it did not look completely out of context.

I wanted to create a flagship model for the brand. Something that was sporting, but had a sense of elegance about it. I deliberately avoided the idea of doing a some form of supercar, aside from the fact it just wouldn’t fit, suggesting I do a super-hyper track machine with a million horsepower and flames coming out the back just isn’t my thing. It lacks a bit of thought in my opinion.

p2140000

My idea was to create a flagship four seater coupe for the MG brand – something to rival the likes of Audi’s A5 and BMW’s 6-Series. After what was possibly the shortest meeting with a tutor ever – I think he could have even filled the form out for me to some extent – the idea was signed off and I could get started.

I got my general proportions by taking the dimensions of all the competitors in the sector and averaged them out. These were never to be the final dimensions of the vehicle, merely a base to get me started on the sketchwork. It was always a given the car would morph and change during the various stages of its development. I relentlessly knocked out side profile after side profile, endlessly altering shape, proportion and plenty of other details – experimenting with different combinations of ideas.

More tutor meetings came and went and the general consensus was positive. I scanned an agreed initial side profile into CAD and just made up a basic shape of the vehicle in order to print off and use as an underlay for three quarter view sketchwork. I also researched MGs of the past, present and future and tried to recreate some design cues onto this concept. Particular influences include the MG EXE, with its low front and high back end, but I also looked at features of the MG6 and Zero Concept.

I carried on sketching, eventually getting to a point where I was happy with the initial idea that I had created and it was time to move on to the next step. This was to create an orthographic front, side, rear, and top view drawing of the vehicle in tenth scale. This would eventually be used as a template and a reference for when I started to make my quarter scale clay model.

I spent roughly three days at the drawing board, ensuring that the design would work on a three dimensional model. I plotted sections across each view of the vehicle, which I could later use as templates for the basic shape of the 3D interpretation. After a presentation declaring my intentions and the orthographic complete, the project was signed off and ready to go into the modelling stage.

p1000001

First of all, the finalised orthographic drawing was scanned in and blown up so that the image was quarter scale size. I had two of these printed – one was pinned up and used for reference while the other was cut up and used to create the templates for the sections that I had plotted in. I had been provided with a table, which was marked with a grid of 100mm squares, so this would allow continuity between the measurements on the drawing and the measurements of the model.

I made a base for the vehicle, made from MDF, and set to the ride height of the design.  Once secured into place I could start glueing polystyrene foam to it. This was then shaped back to the rough shape of the vehicle, but 15 to 20mm smaller around all surfaces. This would be taken up by the clay, this was applied thinly all over the model first of all. Then the sections that I had made were clamped into place and I then built the clay up to the edge dictated by those sections.

Once the sections were removed, the build up of clay in those places had effectively split the car up into eight sections. These were then built up one by one, until eventually the loading of the clay was complete and I could start surfacing. To do this I took points off the drawing and plotted them onto the model – I marked styling lines and creases etc, with low tack 4mm tape so that I knew where to surface. This is where reality struck and taught me a lesson regarding my design work. In the past, I would create sketches without much regard for how easily it would actually translate into 3D. I would just innocently cast pen to paper and assume it could be done.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

Doing this model taught me how significant even a basic line on a drawing is in real life, how it can quite drastically affect the form of the vehicle to the point it can just look completely incorrect. I was certainly an insight into the world of concept model making. Generally though, in my mind, things were going well and the vehicle was starting to take shape in some areas. Then there was another review.

That didn’t go well. The tutors weren’t convinced. General thought was that the idea was dated and some elements just didn’t work. I protested to some extent and pointed out via research that the things that I had done had reasoning behind them. That wasn’t accepted and a rethink was required. Honestly, by the time I got out of that room I just wanted to bin the model. I’d worked hard up to this point and being knocked back like that was humiliating. I went home, took a couple of days out and got my thoughts together. I got more feedback from the review, the form was generally okay, but most of the features needed work.

I started sketching again and it didn’t take me long to realise the tutors were right. I could do better. I knocked up a rough three quarter sketch and took it in to the workshop to see what I could do. It was a massive improvement straight away and certainly what it needed.

I carried on, experimenting further with some features to see what would work best – one thing I loved about the clay was that I could alter surfaces infinitely without it being too much of a pain. An informal review resulted in happier tutors and I continued on my way.

Eventually, I had everything on one side roughed in and it was time to start transferring these features over to the other side of the model. This involved a bridge structure that straddled the model and could be moved back and forth depending on where I was working. Vernier gauges, profile gauges, adjustable right angles and many, many rulers were also in use during this stage. Points would be taken in 50mm squares over one side of the vehicle and then plotted on to the other side. Points were built up using clay and marked at the correct position using correction fluid. For more intricate features, more points were taken to aid the translation to the other side.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

That stage took roughly two weeks alone. Once it was complete the surfacing of the car was refined as a whole. I then applied modelling film, which had been painted in Nightfire Red. I also borrowed a friend’s painted Silver. This was done to inspect reflections and light lines on the vehicle to ensure nothing would look odd or out of place on the finished, painted model.

Once I was happy with this, the model was refined further and then flipped upside down to tidy up underneath. Final surfacing refinement was carried out using small fine slicks. On inspection by the clay modelling technician, the model was complete and ready for the next step.

The clay was to be used as a tool to create a mould for a GRP body. This was my first experience with using fibreglass and I had my reservations – in particular, I did not want to ruin several months of hard work put into the clay to end up with nothing. I was reassured by the workshop technicians and with their guidance made a start.

The clay was sprayed with a blue substance which in this case would act as a release agent in order for us to release the mould. Once this was dry the car was shuttered off into sections, this was to be a seven part mould. The shuttering was excess lengths clay pinned to the model using bicycle spokes. It was quite gut wrenching poking those into my model! Once that was done I could get started, doing each section one by one applying gel coat and two different grades of matting.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

This seemed to go well and my confidence was building. Once all the sections were complete, it was trimmed to make it a little less awkward to handle and each part of the mould was released individually.

I use the term “released” very loosely! What was involved was several mallets, wedges and a drill – by the end of the torture the clay was utterly destroyed. However, the good news was it had provided a good mould so it had done the job it was intended for. The mould was reconstructed, cleaned with a pressure washer and then release wax was applied in readiness for the fibreglass of the final body.

Doing the final body was a far quicker process and was done within a few hours. It was the height of summer and it was hot with low humidity. The body cured remarkably quickly. Release of the body was a mildly easier process, with only one small blemish to repair on the front end. Once that was sorted, it was sent off to a local bodyshop to be painted.

Going to pick the body up from the shop was quite exciting, I was amazed at the job they had done and never imagined it was going to look as good as it did. I took it back home and started applying vinyls I had drawn up and cut for the windows, lights and various other details and trim. During this time I also got the wheels sorted – the tyre section was made from MDF, cut and shaped on a lathe, while the “alloy” inners were rapid prototyped from a design I had drawn and made on the University’s Prototyping Machine. The MDF was primed and then painted by myself, as were the inners which were resin casts of the prototypes in order to create a set of four. They were painted Gunmetal Grey, with black enamel sections – this was inspired by the Rostyle wheels of the MGBs.

p1000002

The model was now complete and to my eyes it looked awesome. To me it is what I feel a modern MG should look like and has an aggressive stance, with sporting qualities and a general whiff of elegance. I was proud of the result and it was an immensely enjoyable process to make something that I had thought of and then drawn, to life. The car went on display at the Graduation Exhibition at Swansea Waterfront Museum, I had my final assessment and then it was all over.

Results day came, I was extremely nervous. All I had to do was log in to the University website. I got a 2:2 with Honours. To say I was gutted was an understatement, knowing that the majority of employers look for 2:1 and above I thought my shot at the car industry was over.

Luckily I was wrong. My model was spotted by a company that creates models and concept vehicles for manufacturers. They took me on for just over a month on a temporary basis, to help out on jobs they had going. Two months after I had finished I was taken back on. Generally, it was good – there were ups and downs, but overall I enjoyed what I was doing. Unfortunately though, in October 2012, I was made redundant and, bar a seasonal retailing job over Christmas, I find myself back out of the Car Industry.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

I’ve been on the hunt for a new position ever since. I know my design work isn’t quite on par with others although I still enjoy sketching, but I love the model making aspect, so that’s the kind of position I’m searching for, particularly clay-based positions. The rejection is tough and I’ve thought about giving up and trying something else numerous times.

My ambition has always been to work at MG as it is a brand I have always been passionate about. I’ve sent portfolios to SAIC Motor UK among others, but they have nothing available for me. Part of me though makes me want it more every time I get turned down, just to make a point.

I’m keeping at it. I know deep down I’ll be back. It’s just a matter of time…

Keith Adams

Keith Adams

Editor and creator AROnline at AROnline
Created www.austin-rover.co.uk in 2001 and built it up to become the world's foremost reference source for all things BMC, Leyland and Rover Group, before renaming it AROnline in 2007.

Is the Editor of the Parkers website and price guide, formerly editor of Classic Car Weekly, and launch editor/creator of Modern Classics magazine. Has contributed to various motoring titles including Octane, Practical Classics, Evo, Honest John, CAR magazine, Autocar, Pistonheads, Diesel Car, Practical Performance Car, Performance French Car, Car Mechanics, Jaguar World Monthly, MG Enthusiast, Modern MINI, Practical Classics, Fifth Gear Website, Radio 4, and the the Motoring Independent...

Likes 'conditionally challenged' motors and taking them on unfeasible adventures all across Europe.
Keith Adams

Latest posts by Keith Adams (see all)

32 Comments

  1. Nice! Great design, would make a great range topper. I do like the A5 aspect, but could never drive a modern Audi.
    Worthy replacement to the Honda cooupe 🙂

    Don’t get too hung up on the desmond (2.2). Thats what I got. Got my foot in the door in IT, few years experience and quietly deleted the grade fro the CV. I now interview candidates, you get to know if they are passionate and knowledgable about a subject, as you seem to be.

    Shame you are struggling tog get this work in the UK. Do the likes of Italdesign / Bertone do apprenticeships? Strings to the bow on the CV.

    You look to have a promising career ahead of you, I suspect we will hear your name in the future 🙂

    Good luck! Excuse grammar / spelling, few sherbits.

  2. I’m thoroughly impressed! Not just with the design, but also the whole model-building process. A very interesting blog! I really hope all this translates into a job for you.

  3. Very nice looking car, ideal mgf/tf replacment, keep at it, SAIC should really look in the model you have produced, I have not seen anything ideas from SIAC yet. Good luck, regards Mark

  4. Great work, not entirely sure about the cabin roofline, but a fantastic peice of design.

    Good luck, although I am resonably sure on this evidence you don’t need it!

  5. My advice is to get in at an automotive in another role and then try and work from within back towards design. You have the talent, it would be a great loss to see it go to waste. Also if you went in doing something else it gives you a wider appreciate of what is needed form a design on a more practical level, such as tooling or day to production constraints. JLR are still recruiting to the best of my knowledge. Try some of the less obvious anvenues too such as Tata who a strong presence at Warwick Uni, or maybe even Morgan or Triunph Motorcycles. As another thought what about design houses that design things other than cars, stuff like white goods, boats. There is a company in Coventry called CGI, who do that sort of work. Might be worth a go.

  6. Wow! Great article…..your story echoes my own in part – I too was obsessed with drawing cars as a child – I created a range of cars, closely based on the ARG range at the time in size (ie, Maestro, Monty, Ambassador etc), and spent hours and hours drawing. I decided at the age of 11 that I wanted to be a car designer.

    When I left school I did a Btec in 3D Design at the local art college, and drifted into product design – I figured that junior car stylists would rarely get let loose on a whole car, whereas product designers could be responsible for a complete design. When it came time to choose a University (Polytechnic back in the early 90s), I looked at Swansea – the course had literally just started then, Coventry and Newcastle. I got offered a place at Cov, but turned it down, and went to Newcastle Poly instead – which turned out to be a smart move, given the later connection with Jonathan Ive (Apple’s design guru).

    I came out with a 2:1, and went to work for a Taiwanese electronics manufacturer, travelling between the UK and Taiwan, developing twin product ranges. I got out of ID after about 4 years though, having had interviewed for jobs with Phillips and IBM, and being offered a post in Taiwan, which I did not want. I then moved first into design and build airport and railway station fit-outs, then into architecture, and then construction, where I now have a design coordinator’s job with a large construction firm.

    It’s a hard ride, design, and I don’t want to deter you in anyway, but from my experience it’s not so much how good your work is (believe me, some of the guys I studied with weren’t the greatest designers by any means, but have stuck with it, and have forged decent careers), it’s more how good you are at self-promotion, who you are able to get your work in front of, and a lot of luck. Knock on as many doors as you can, enter competitions, self-publicise.

    If you can, get into an area of the country where automotive design is still an industry – I’m guessing around Warwickshire and near where the F1 constructors are would be favourite – knock on doors, and offer your services. Keep up to date with the CAD software (this is where I got out of ID – I like drawing and making models, not operating software). Most of all, forget about your degree grade – mine’s not even relevant to the job I have now! It’s what you can do that counts, not what bits of paper you have.

    Finally, if you can afford it, go an do the MA course at the RCA – it will instantly put you in touch with the right people in the industry, and will supersede your BA grade. Good luck, keep us informed of your progress, and new design work.

  7. Ben This is exactly what I wanted to be, At School whilst everyone I knew was into Football and other things whist I collected Car Magazines, especially ones that had features on Car Design (still have them) I even sent my Design proposal for the new Sierra to Ford Motor Co, I was quite confident they would be delighted in my rendering which was a rather swoopy looking thing which dare I say wouldnt have looked out of place in the early naughty’s…

    However They later sent it back with a polite letter in advising there are certain procedures in undertaking any Design, accompanied with a Ford Stamp in the middle of the picture (must dig it out sometime) Incidentally the Headlights were quite similar to the later facelift Mk1 Mondeo ! Though not much else..

    It is the biggest kick in the Kn*ckers when what you think is brilliant is turned down, On the last day at School a couple of years later (The Sierra had been given its 1st facelift I think?) We were asked “What did we all want to be?” most replies were Plumber, Electrician, Mechanic etc, but I got a hell of a Laugh when I said Car Designer, Even the Teacher was Gob smacked.

    My Dream slipped away after that and settled for Mechanic and later Plant operator, whist I gave up completely I admire that you have not, Your Hard work will pay off !

  8. Ben… your design sketches look great and the model is awesome! If MG actually built this car based on your designs I would join the queue to buy. Love the purple convertible too.

    You are the sort of Designer that this country really needs and needs right now. I wish you all the best and hope you achieve your ambition.

  9. Very sound advice from No9 there. Especially regarding keeping up to date with the software etc. and the relevance in the longer term of your 2.2 (a ‘Desmond’?)

  10. Thanks for the great comments guys. I really appreciate it.
    If any of you are on facebook, I have a page set up there, just search for Ben Richards Design.

    Tony – I have already worked for CGI.

  11. I am full of admiration because you had the persistence to see your ideas translated into reality . I hope you will now have the persistence to keep trying for a further opportunity to gain experience because as a nation we need people like you . Good luck!!

  12. Ben, like you I have had a great interest in cars from a very young age. My obsession since the late 70’s has been BL > MG UK. Similarly, I’m not to sure what led to this obsession, certainly not family ownership.

    As a very young lad I suppose I aspired to be a car designer. Somehow though later education did not lead me down this route & I ended up with a degee in Business Studies! I still wanted to work with cars, however. My industrial placement whilst at Polytechnic had been with Plaxton, the coachbuilder – not a bad start. However, the closest I have come since is my job of the last two years working for a packaging company whose main customer is JLR, just down the road. I hope that it’s not too late to work in a much more automotive environment!

    Anyway, getting to my main points –

    (i) Your MG is quite stunning! Also, I think it is a good interpretion of a modern MG.

    (ii) I can appreciate your frustration at your present situation – at least to some extent. The best of luck in finding and securing your ideal job!

  13. Well done Ben. I have been drawing cars (like so many others here) since I was about 10. in the 70’s and 80’s I had a complete range from mini to limo with sports alongside. I was told at a very young age that I could never get into car design or styling because my maths weren’t good enough. However, I do have dated original sketches (to scale) of saloons with the bonnet and screen in the same plane long before a car was released like it. I don’t think that is particularly clever, loads of you must have done it too – it was an obvious development. I also used the Renault 5 door handle on many models before Renault released the 5. I have virtually got the Smart Car dated early 80’s. I knew I could draw from scratch a really attractive car – and I badge engineered them using such names as Alvis, Armstrong, Lanchester as well as my own range names. All pie in the sky – just dreams and no where near the skill and capability you have Ben.
    Just don’t ever give up (easy for me to say). I understand some of the world’s greatest stylist are hopeless at maths! I wonder where I’d be now if I had not listened to my Head Master!

  14. Ben, this is a brilliant piece of work and the best news about ‘new MG’ that I have seen for a very long time – this is what the MG brand is all about, not the Skoda/Kia/Hyundai competitor that SAIC are developing it into. Good luck with your future automotive career which I sincerely hope is with MG.

  15. Very contemporary. Not sure if that was what you wanted, but it certainly looks bang up to date.

    Widen your horizons to get a job. Look for smaller companies that just want a bit of design and practical skills. As stated above, after a few years nobody will care about the desmond but will be interested in what you’ve done professionally.

    Chris.

  16. These are very inspiring designs!

    What immediately strikes me is how Ben has approached the often rather controversial aspect of designing an all-new MG (Think the mafia in the form of the two main MG clubs in the UK, not to mention a army of rose-tinted enthusiasts who can’t see life beyond the MGB) from a different perspective to other designers. In other words, he has not allowed himself to be constrained by MG’s heritage or feel obliged to to conform to it by adopting numerous design cues from classic MGs. Far from it.

    This is why I like his proposals, because they look modern, cohesive and not constrained by heritage. There is also an element of strength and quality about the designs where they could cut it with more premium brands. They also won’t date as much because there is no retro element about them and no obvious parts bins influence either. This is really what any new MG should be about as there quite simply is no strength in the brand itself anymore whereby it can escape the associations of suviving on nostalgia, cost-led parts bin reliance and badge engineering exercises.

  17. Ben:

    If you are ever up for another challenge I would love to see your ideas for a future luxury Rover Coupe (think modern day P5B Coupe or CCV) or a luxury Daimler saloon posted on here. Particularly based on my previous comments about the way you have handled the MG challenge.

    Before anyone argues, I am aware that there is little chance of either name making a return in the near future, if at all. However, I have recently seen other design students’ work for a new Triumph sports car based on BMW running gear and platform (Triumph itself also being a dormant marque). For Triumph enthusiasts attending the recent Classic Motor Show, it was interesting to see how someone had ‘dusted off the name’, given a cautious glance to the potential heritage rut and come up with a new interpretation for a future Triumph.

  18. @27

    Might be an interesting exercise to run past Tata/JLR. They are thinking of producing a sub-premium range of cars (the Rover concept…) and if they ever needed a competitor to the Rolls Royce / Bentley brand, Daimler would probably be more successful than Maybach was…

  19. Nice contemporary piece of design. Problem for Ben is that jobs are so hard to come by in this sector. Just a few designers in the UK at this level and only a few companies to choose from. Suggest you try a job in the automotive industry first and then look to get transferred internally. Product Planing might be a possibility. Have you tried the Graduate route or failing that offer to do a three month placement through your University. the places are subsidised and you might get a foot in the door. Also look at Knowledge Transfer Parnerships run by the Gov through Universities. Usually need a 2:1 for that but with your skill their might be exceptions. Speak to the KTP manager in your area again through your University.

  20. As a child i wanted to be a car designer too, but I ended up as a journalist instead! Anyway, your work looks great and i can only wish you all the best as you pursue your dream. If MG takes you up on this design you have shown here they’ll definitely have a winner on their hands. Do you have any interior sketches or ideas on possible powertrains for this vehicle?

  21. Thanks Guys.

    The uni still has a lot of my sketchwork and that includes interior ideas. Powertrain wise I was looking at 2 Litres and upwards, for a range topper I avoided a V8 due to economics and went for a 3.0 V6 Twin Turbo Diesel, with electric motor assist and kinetic energy recovery.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*