Predicting the future – 25 years too early
Suggest buying a Toyota Prius and people will smile then nod approvingly. It’s cool to be seen to be doing your bit for the environment by buying an alternatively-propelled car. But tell those same friends that you always hankered after a Sinclair C5 and they will merely snigger and consider you rather strange for doing so. Strange, then, that Sir Clive Sinclair produced 12,000 C5s in nine months, and it took Toyota a whole lot longer… and cost rather more.
Sir Clive had already given the public accessible future technology. Though it was a Texas or Casio calculator that ultimately graced the executive desk of the 1970s, it had been the Sinclair pocket calculator of 1972 that started the ball rolling. Almost ten years later, the kit-build ZX80 led to the creation of the swish looking ready-made ZX81, which truly kick-started the home computer revolution in the UK. In short, Sinclair Research was the UK’s Apple of its generation – giving the market exactly what it wanted, even though (customers) never knew they needed it.
The C5 was no different – except it was a quarter of a century premature.
Providing the spark
The Electrically Assisted Pedal Cycle Regulations of 1983:
Boffins at the UK Transport and Road Research Laboratory configured this new legislation, the Department of Transport rubber stamped it. Sinclair then exploited these new rules to the max, ruthlessly.
Simply any ‘electrically assisted cycle’ constructed to these regulations had to weigh less than 60kg, contain an electric motor rated at (no more than) 250W and meet British standard pedal cycle braking specifications.
So if Sinclair could meet these specifications anyone over 14 could legally ride a C5 without need for any license, insurance or road taxation (or a protective helmet – a socially outrageous concept 25 years later).
The secret factory
Of course it’s hard to share a vision without a physical product. Or hard cash. The Electricity council had previously funded £5.5 million pounds of research grants (£2.3 million alone to the Lucas/GM electric van) however (apart from a favourable set of regulations) Sinclair’s funding came via a 10% sale of Sinclair Research ltd. With The Engineer Magazine reporting Sinclair ploughing £12.9 million pounds of his own funds into the project. So having secured the funding a production line was sought.
Originally Sinclair’s aim was for the C5 to be the foothold of a whole range of electric vehicles, so when an Option on the ashes of John Z DeLorean’s Northern Irish facility came up Sinclair voiced an interest. Sitting idle was a purpose built vehicle assembly line embracing many modern production methods at a knock down price with a workforce and government backing to boot. At the same time Sinclair Vehicles Ltd (SVL) was established, based at the University of Warwick Science Park.
Early in 1984 the seemingly well informed Engineer magazine claimed an announcement was poised (for the ashes of DeLorean), though ultimately an arrangement could not be brokered. Undaunted the Welsh Development Agency stepped in: Hoover (the American vacuum cleaner conglomerate) had a modern facility in deepest Merthyr Tydfil with space and workforce to spare. With a planned production volume of 200,000 vehicles a year, Hoover became interested enough
to spend £100,000 on a satellite factory within the existing complex.
Starting with six members of staff in a sealed room, the project was sworn to secrecy, such that the only scoop prior to launch was six months later in the Mail on Sunday, November 1984. In fact all parties involved in the project treated it with the kind of security normally reserved for a new car launch. Hoover staff trial assembled 100 C5s prior to full production, pulling them apart before reassembling. Potentially 50 C5s could be produced per line per hour – with a capability of a massive 8000 C5s a week…
Of course Hoover’s other angle came in the form of 19 service centres, 400 engineers and recommend six monthly servicing of the C5. A healthy contract on 200,000 projected vehicles.
Where there’s a Wills – there’s a way
While Sinclair had an Engineering aptitude, it was from the electronic rather than production background. However an opportunity presented itself in the form of a casualty from the Delorean debacle – Barrie Wills. Wills had a sound background in automobile lost causes – apprenticed at Jaguar, part of the team behind the Leyland National, Managing Director of Reliant before joining the board of DeLorean – all in the space of 20 years.
Of course Wills was sceptical of an electric car, but agreed to meet Sinclair regardless – despite being Delorean’s longest serving employee, the receivers’ were in control of the Belfast factory. Wills had a good relationship with Lotus in Hethel (so much so he would eventually father the front wheel drive Elan) and became the bridge between Lotus and Sinclair.
Formula one design
Already development had begun at Ogle design (Tom Karen’s design house responsible for the Scimitar and the Raleigh Chopper cycle amongst others). Sinclair aided by Tony Wood Rogers had a spent a year with Ogle honing the prototype, but the design was faltering and getting heavier – 100kg, then 150kg. So when Wills arrived in March 1983, Ogle and Sinclair curtailed their association and transferred development to Hethel – home of Lotus.
At Lotus brothers Brian & Colin Spooner examined what they had inherited; a design study with a set of regulations. Although the design was reworked by Lotus (dropping its drag co-efficient of friction from 0.95 to 0.6), Sinclair employed a young graduate fresh from the Royal school of art’s industrial design course – Guy Desbarats. Desbarats revised the design and added flush wheel trims, in addition to a small boot tweaking the C5’s Bond Bug-esque rear pillar.
Hethel’s chassis design guru’s set to work on the pressed steel chassis. The design had many parallels with the humble ski – great torsional strength made by two pieces of pressed steel joined in a sandwich, whilst giving enough flex to create a suspension effect. Over 19 months, the design was tested extensively – not just at Lotus’s Hethel test track, but at the Motor Industry Research Association (MIRA) test facility. The C5 was subjected to every surface and test condition bar the famous banked oval. Uniquely the C5 crash testing found that no injury was likely in a collision simulation up to the C5’s maximum speed (15mph).
For a little piece of competition pedigree, the Bugatti owners club even opened up Prescott hill climb so lotus could put development miles
on the C5!
Though originally sceptical of the whole commission for Sinclair, ultimately the Spooner brothers were won over – to quote Colin, ‘It is a remarkably stable vehicle, it performs very well, and it’s safe. It is neither a toy or a plaything.’ To quote Brian, ‘The C5 is an extremely reliable piece of engineering, which I am convinced, will in time become even more sophisticated.’
Of course the C5 aided other automotive technology – its electronic display unit was created by AB Automotive Electronics. The next electronic display from AB would be the ‘Tokyo by night’ instrument cluster of the forthcoming Jaguar XJ40…
Body moulding Maestro
At launch it was established that the C5 had the world’s ‘Largest, mass produced injection moulding’. A bold claim and backed up by the UK industry big-hitters. ICI supplied the white/grey pigmented plastic polypropylene – any scuffs or scratches just revealed the same hue – with Linpac manufacturing the two-piece shell. The practice involved injection moulding the upper part of the shell complete, and moulding the lower part complete.
Then a ‘tape’ would be placed between both halves of the shell whilst in a jig. The last stage was to ‘cure’ this tape by passing an electric current through it, effectively fusing the two halves (of the bodyshell) together. The total time taken for this process was just 70 seconds. A year earlier, in 1983, one of the first uses for this type of assembly was seen in the Austin Maestro – both its front and rear Bokan bumpers were moulded this way…
While the moulded bodyshell waited, the assembly of the chassis began – wheels, tyres, bearing and steering were fitted. With the electric DC motor installed, further electrics (lights) are fitted to the complete shell before it clothes the rolling chassis. Just like a new car, the virgin C5s were rolling road tested on a special jig – which replicated a 12 stone body weight – before being rolled into cardboard packaging for transport direct from the line to waiting trucks.
As owners regularly found out, battery technology had kind of stalled. In reality until the mobile cellular telephone became common place ten years later, battery technology not massively removed from the turn of the century. Undaunted Sinclair made the most of what was commercially available – his personal belief being that once electric vehicles became popular, battery manufactures would up the ante and pay for the development themselves.
Joe Caine became Sinclair’s battery man. An ex-employee of Chloride he contacted Sinclair by letter; one successful CV application later and he had his own lab in Bolton complete with £10,000 of testing equipment. In conjunction with Oldham batteries he developed a battery which withstood Sinclair’s remit 300 charge/discharge cycles. In four hours a C5 could be 80 per cent charged, in eight hours 100 per cent charged. Because the C5 weighed 30kg and the battery (a 12V 36ah item) 15kg, it meant a spare could be carried and still not exceed the 60kg maximum of the new regulations.
Meanwhile Rogers had found his first suitable electric motor – originally envisaged for a truck cooling fan. However the Bosch item was replaced by an Italian item, unfortunately from a company that also manufactured washing machine motors. Something the press quickly picked up on…
It was hoped that a 20-mile range was possible from a single charge, boosted by using the ‘push and coast’ system of driving. Quite simply you accelerated, eased off the (electric) throttle, coasted then accelerated again.
Sinclair Vehicles launched the C5 on Thursday the 10th of January 1985 at Alexandra Palace in London. (Home of the first TV transmission in November 1936 by the BBC). The following day the C5 made the front page of most national newspapers, followed by the invitation for the public to try the C5 over that weekend. Over 100 Electricity board showrooms had a C5 on display to tantalise consumers.
Sinclair and Wills were upbeat during the press conference in which six C5s burst out of packaging on stage and circled the arena. A development film then showed the C5 being tested and amongst the more sensible sales patter rather bizarrely Wills informed the journalists present that seating position was based upon that of the Ford Capri! The press pack also made much of the fact that the drivers eye level in traffic was comparable to the mini, but with a turning circle two thirds of Mini’s – not an amazing boast.
It was anticipated that over 100,000 vehicles could be produced in 1985, creating 200 jobs, and that as of 10.30am that day (during the press conference), it was confirmed that precisely 2507 C5s had been constructed so far. It was announced in addition to Hoover’s maintenance back up electrical retailer COMET had won the contract to handle replacement battery sales, with Woolworths additionally waiting in the wings. The Royal Society for the Prevention of accidents were represented too, assuring the press of the C5’s safety and handing out fact sheets.
The advertising plans for the new C5 were outlined, the main thrust of the £3m advertising campaign being TV commercials (even though the UK had just two commercial stations at the time.)
‘Imagine a vehicle that can drive you five miles for a penny; a vehicle that needs no petrol, just a battery; and that takes the press of a button to start, the squeeze of a lever to stop. That needs no licence, no road tax, and you can drive it whether your 14 or 40. A vehicle that costs just £399. The Sinclair C5 is a new power in personal transport. The Sinclair C5. £399. Want to buy one? Or simply want to read all about it? Just dial 100 and ask for free phone C5 – NOW.’
Persuasive stuff indeed. Final thanks were given to all the companies who had supported the project, then the floor was open to questions before the obligatory test drives. The overall response was all rather favourable. So what went wrong?
The dream discharges
Despite claimed orders approaching a 1000 units for the first week, and 5000 sales for the first month after launch, in reality approximately 7500 C5s were sold by Sinclair Vehicles – an impressive figure were it not for the additional 4500 unsold C5s.
Though available direct (with a crafty £29 delivery charge added to the £399 retail price) by the summer of 1985 COMET stores were offering C5s with free delivery. On 13th August, Hoover announced it was to cease production of the C5 due to the stock pile of unsold units. A last ditch attempt by COMET to retail the C5 at a slashed price of £139.99 (delivered to your doorstep) in September did little to stop the receivers being called on the 12th October.
Total debts at the point of liquidation were £6.4m, (Hoover’s debt alone standing at £1.5m). In an effort to recoup some cash the remaining 4500 C5s were sold by the liquidators, however as manufacture was outsourced nothing much else existed to offset the debts.
There are many theories to the downfall of the C5, but perception and price and the two fickle favourites. Worthy as electric transport was, in 1985 the world was not ready to save the planet – but it could justify a front loading video recorder with remote control, or a compact disc player. If you needed personal transport a new cycle was just 20 per cent of the C5’s purchase price, and people didn’t stare at you on your way to work.
Therein lied problem number two – possibly the reason behind the C5’s downfall. Nobody dared be seen struggling to propel a C5 uphill with articulated trucks inches from your torso. Combine that with quizzical stares and finger pointing of the bemused general public and your pool of purchasers narrows considerably.
Alas the C5 was a visionary idea that just appeared in the wrong century.
Sinclair timeline 1958-1986
1958 Leaves school Editor Practical Wireless
1961 Formed Sinclair Radionics
1962 Microamplifier – smaller than a half-crown. Joins MENSA
1966 Microvision TV (£99.95). Chris Curry joins
1968 System 2000 complete hi-fi system
1972 First calculator – Sinclair Executive (£79.95)
1973 Cambridge calculator (£29.95) Nigel Searle joins
1976 Company loses £335,000. NEB buys a 43% stake for £650,000
1977 Collapse of calculator market. NEB injects further £1.9m.
1978 £2m loss. First microcomputer designed and sold to Newbury Labs. Emerges two years later as the New Brain.
1979 Sinclair splits from NEB. Sets up Science of Cambridge with Chris Curry. Curry splits off and sets up Acorn. Sinclair sets up Sinclair Research.
1980 ZX80 (£99.95)
1982 Spectrum launched 16K (£125) 48K (£175). 300,000 ZX81s sold. Turn-over up to £30m
1983 Spectrums sell at 12,000 week. Microdrives (£49.95). Sinclair is Guardian Young Businessman and is knighted in the Queen’s Birthday Honours. Flat Screen TV (£79.95)
1984 QL (£399). Turn-over up to £77m. Flotation of 10% values Sinclair Research at £134m. Spectrum Plus (£179)
1985 C5 launched by Sinclair Vehicles. Cash crisis at Sinclair Research. Maxwell steps in, and out. £10m raised by sale Spectrum to Dixons
1986 Spectrum 128 (£179). Amstrad takes over computer business. Sinclair moves on.
Words: Andrew Elphick Pictures: SinclairC5.com unless otherwise indicated.
Now he’s busy working towards retirement. Hmm.
Latest posts by Andrew Elphick (see all)
- Events : Geneva Motor Show 2018 – the punter’s viewpoint - 11 March 2018
- News : AROnline’s winter driving tips - 2 March 2018
- Blog : Pound shop or premium? - 22 November 2017